Randomised controlled trial · 2020
Oral dapoxetine versus topical lidocaine as on-demand treatment for lifelong premature ejaculation: A randomised controlled trial
Alghobary M, Gaballah M, El-Kamel MF, State AF, Ismail SR, Selim MK, Mostafa T (2020). Oral dapoxetine versus topical lidocaine as on-demand treatment for lifelong premature ejaculation: A randomised controlled trial. Andrologia. doi:10.1111/and.13558
In a crossover trial in men with lifelong PE, a 10% lidocaine spray lengthened latency more than on-demand dapoxetine 60 mg over 12 weeks each, and more men rated it effective, but erection scores fell with lidocaine and not with dapoxetine.
Summary
This Egyptian randomised crossover trial compared two on-demand treatments for lifelong premature ejaculation (PE): dapoxetine 60 mg by mouth and a 10% lidocaine spray applied to the penis. Each man started with one treatment for 12 weeks, had a two-week wash-out, then used the other for 12 weeks. The researchers recorded intravaginal ejaculatory latency time (IELT: the time from penetration to ejaculation), a PE symptom index (AIPE), an erection score (SHIM) and how often couples had intercourse.
Both treatments improved latency and symptom scores compared with baseline, and the lidocaine spray improved latency significantly more than dapoxetine. When asked whether each treatment worked, 43 men rated lidocaine effective and 12 ineffective, while 16 rated dapoxetine effective and 39 ineffective. Erection scores fell significantly with lidocaine but not with dapoxetine.
Limitations
The trial was from a single country, and the abstract does not state clearly how many men were randomised; from the efficacy-question counts, about 55 men completed both phases. The abstract reports latency figures (63.44 s and 179.4 s against a baseline of 21.87 s) without making fully clear which value belongs to which treatment phase. There was no placebo arm, and men could tell which treatment they were using. A 10% lidocaine spray is stronger per application than many products, so results may not apply to every spray.
What it means for you
A lidocaine spray can be at least as effective as an on-demand pill for lifelong PE, and some men prefer it. The trade-off is local: reduced sensation can make erections less firm, so use the lowest dose that works, and talk to a doctor if erections are already a concern.