Skip to content
Ejaculation.org

Medication

Best Delay Spray? An Independent, Evidence-Graded Comparison

Which delay spray is best for premature ejaculation? Fortacin, Promescent, Stud 100 and lidocaine creams graded on ingredients, licensing and trial evidence.

Short answer

There is no single best delay spray, but the one with the strongest evidence is the licensed lidocaine–prilocaine spray (Fortacin), tested in randomized placebo-controlled trials. US over-the-counter lidocaine sprays such as Promescent and Stud 100 contain about 10 mg of lidocaine per spray; their ingredient works, but product-specific evidence is thin.

Updated · sources listed at the end of this page

By The Ejaculation.org Editorial TeamUpdated 8 min read

Key takeaways

  • No delay spray is the best for everyone; the right choice depends on licensing, evidence, condom use, whether you're trying to conceive and how much numbness you tolerate.
  • The licensed lidocaine–prilocaine spray has the strongest evidence: in a 256-man trial, average latency rose from 0.56 to 2.60 minutes over three months, versus 0.53 to 0.80 on placebo.
  • Promescent and Stud 100 are US over-the-counter lidocaine sprays with about 10 mg of lidocaine per spray; lidocaine works as a class, but neither product has a published placebo-controlled trial.
  • In 91 men with lifelong PE, three sprays of the licensed spray 5 minutes before sex worked better than one or five sprays or longer waits.
  • In a laboratory study, a lidocaine delay spray reduced sperm motility and viability, so couples trying to conceive should avoid delay sprays and ask a doctor.

There is no single best delay spray, but there is a clear difference in evidence. The licensed lidocaine–prilocaine spray sold as Fortacin is the only delay spray tested in large placebo-controlled trials in men with premature ejaculation (PE) (Carson & Wyllie, 2010). US over-the-counter lidocaine sprays such as Promescent and Stud 100 use an ingredient that works as a class, but evidence for the products themselves is thin.

This is an independent comparison. We take no affiliate commissions, link to no shop and name no winner. Instead we grade each product on criteria you can check yourself, list products alphabetically and show our sources. For how numbing products work, side effects and partner transfer in general, read our guide to delay sprays and numbing creams first. All of these sit within the wider premature ejaculation medication options covered in our complete guide to premature ejaculation.

How we graded delay sprays

We used six criteria, chosen because each one changes either how well a spray is likely to work or how safe it is for you and your partner:

  1. Active ingredient and strength, read from the official label or product information, not the marketing page.
  2. Regulatory status: a licensed medicine assessed by a regulator, or a US over-the-counter product sold under the federal rules for "male genital desensitizers".
  3. Product-specific evidence: published trials of that exact product, graded by design (placebo-controlled beats uncontrolled).
  4. Dose and timing as directed on the label.
  5. Partner and condom notes stated in official documents.
  6. Price per use, which you calculate yourself, because prices change: divide the price by the number of uses in the bottle (sprays in the bottle divided by sprays per use).

We included only products whose official labels we could read in full. Many other sprays are sold online; if a product doesn't state its active ingredient and strength, it fails criterion 1 and we wouldn't use it.

Which delay spray has the best evidence?

Product (A–Z)Active ingredientStatusProduct-specific evidenceDirections
FortacinLidocaine 7.5 mg + prilocaine 2.5 mg per sprayLicensed medicine in the EU and UK for lifelong PEPlacebo-controlled phase III trials; dose-timing trial3 sprays on the glans, 5 minutes before sex; max 3 doses in 24 h, 4 h apart
Lidocaine–prilocaine cream (e.g. EMLA)Lidocaine + prilocaineLicensed for skin numbing; off-label for PESmall placebo-controlled trials (pooled 43 men)Applied before sex, then washed off or covered with a condom
PromescentLidocaine, about 10 mg per sprayUS over the counterOne uncontrolled 14-day diary study3 to 10 sprays to head and shaft, 10 minutes before sex, rubbed in; wash off after
Stud 100Lidocaine 9.6% w/w, about 10 mg per sprayUS over the counterNo published trial found3 to 10 sprays to head and shaft before sex; no more than 24 sprays in 24 h; wash off after

Sources: the Fortacin Summary of Product Characteristics; the DailyMed labels for Promescent and Stud 100; trials cited below.

The US rules allow only two ingredients in over-the-counter desensitizers: benzocaine at 3 to 7.5% in a water-soluble base, or lidocaine as a metered spray of about 10 mg per spray (21 CFR 348.10). That's why Promescent and Stud 100 deliver the same amount of lidocaine per spray. The differences between them lie in the base they're dissolved in, directions and price, not in the drug dose.

Is Fortacin the best delay spray?

Fortacin is the delay spray with the strongest evidence. In a phase III trial of 256 men with lifelong PE, average latency rose from 0.56 to 2.60 minutes over three months, versus 0.53 to 0.80 minutes on placebo (Carson & Wyllie, 2010). Latency here means intravaginal ejaculatory latency time (IELT): the time from penetration to ejaculation. The product information reports pooled phase III results in which geometric mean latency rose from 0.58 to 3.17 minutes, versus 0.56 to 0.94 minutes on placebo, and 85.2% of men on the spray averaged more than one minute, versus 46.4% on placebo (SmPC).

It is also the only spray with a dose-and-timing study. In 91 men with lifelong PE, three sprays applied 5 minutes before intercourse worked better than one or five sprays, or than waiting 15 or 30 minutes (Cai et al., 2023). More was not better.

Practical points from the product information: the most common side effects were genital numbness (4.5%) and erection difficulties (4.4%) in men, and a burning sensation (3.9%) in female partners. It must not be used with polyurethane condoms, which deteriorated in testing, but showed no deterioration with latex, polyisoprene, nitrile or silicone ones (SmPC). It is authorised across the EU for lifelong PE (EMA), and the European urology guideline considers medication first-line treatment for lifelong PE (Salonia et al., 2025). It is not FDA-approved, because no medicine is approved for PE in the US (Shindel et al., 2022).

Does lidocaine–prilocaine cream (EMLA) work for PE?

It can, modestly, but it is a general-purpose numbing cream, licensed for skin anesthesia and used off-label for PE. A systematic review pooled two small trials (43 men) and found it increased latency significantly more than placebo (Martyn-St James et al., 2016). In a three-way comparison in 273 men with lifelong PE, the cream lengthened latency more than benzocaine condoms but less than a lidocaine spray (Hamarat et al., 2025). Creams are harder to dose and spread more easily, so they are usually covered with a condom or washed off before intercourse. Ask a doctor or pharmacist before using it this way.

Does Promescent work?

Its ingredient does; the product-specific evidence is weak. Lidocaine products as a class lengthen latency more than placebo in randomized trials (Martyn-St James et al., 2016). The only published study of Promescent itself followed 91 men with self-reported subjective PE for 14 days: average latency was 11.16 minutes on occasions when they used the spray and 6.81 minutes when they didn't (Mark & Kerner, 2016). There was no placebo, men chose when to use it, their latency without it was already around 7 minutes, and one author had manufacturer funding.

Two label details are worth knowing. The Promescent label directs 3 to 10 sprays 10 minutes before intercourse, rubbed in until absorbed, and washed off afterwards, and it warns against use if your partner is or may be pregnant (DailyMed). And in a laboratory study of 20 normal semen samples, mixing in Promescent significantly reduced sperm motility and viability (Sutton et al., 2018). That was a test-tube setting, not real-world use, but it is a reason to avoid delay sprays while trying to conceive.

Does Stud 100 work?

Its ingredient works, but Stud 100 itself has no published trial. It is a US over-the-counter lidocaine spray with lidocaine 9.6% w/w, about 10 mg per spray. Its label directs 3 to 10 sprays to the head and shaft of the penis before intercourse, washing off afterwards, and no more than 24 sprays in 24 hours; it also warns against use if you or your partner are allergic to local anesthetics or if your partner is pregnant (DailyMed).

The closest evidence is a randomized crossover trial of a generic 10% lidocaine spray in men with lifelong PE, which lengthened latency more than on-demand dapoxetine 60 mg; erection scores fell with the spray, though, and not with dapoxetine (Alghobary et al., 2020). That trial used a similar concentration, not this product.

Lidocaine vs benzocaine: which is better?

Head-to-head evidence is limited. In US over-the-counter products, lidocaine comes as metered sprays and benzocaine mostly as wipes, gels and condom linings (21 CFR 348.10). In the one randomized comparison, a lidocaine spray lengthened latency more than benzocaine condoms, while the condoms caused the fewest side effects (Hamarat et al., 2025). That compares delivery methods as much as ingredients. A 5% benzocaine condom added roughly a minute over an ordinary condom in a manufacturer-run trial (Coupland et al., 2026).

Delay spray vs wipes: which should you choose?

Choose by how consistently you can apply a small dose. A metered spray delivers a fixed amount per press. Delay wipes are usually benzocaine-based; Promescent's delay wipes, for example, contain benzocaine 7% (DailyMed). Wipes are discreet and easy to carry, but the dose depends on how you wipe. No trial has compared the two. Our guide to numbing sprays and creams covers topical products in detail.

Delay spray vs Viagra: which works better?

They treat different things. A spray reduces sensation in the penis. Sildenafil (Viagra) and other PDE5 inhibitors improve erections; a meta-analysis of 15 trials found they increased latency more than placebo, but most trials were of unclear quality (Martyn-St James et al., 2017). If you also have erection problems, the European urology guideline puts treating that underlying cause first (Salonia et al., 2025), and a numbing spray could make them worse. See premature ejaculation and erectile dysfunction.

How to get the most from any delay spray

  1. Start at the lowest labeled dose

    Three sprays is the starting point on every label above, and three sprays worked best in the only dose-finding trial, which tested the licensed lidocaine–prilocaine spray (Cai et al., 2023).

  2. Time it as the label says

    5 minutes for Fortacin, 10 minutes for Promescent. Waiting longer did not help in the dose-timing trial.

  3. Remove the excess

    Wipe off or rub in as directed so less reaches your partner. US labels tell you to wash the product off after intercourse.

  4. Check your condom

    If you rely on condoms, avoid polyurethane with Fortacin, and check any other product's label.

  5. Judge it over several uses

    Note how long you lasted and how much sensation you kept. If the spray dulls sex too much or weakens your erection, use fewer sprays rather than switching to a stronger product.

Is a delay spray enough on its own?

For some men it is all they want. But a spray works only on the nights you use it, and it reduces sensation rather than training control. Whether men with PE actually have more sensitive skin is still debated; see penile sensitivity and premature ejaculation. Combining medication with non-drug training has outperformed medication alone in a meta-analysis of eight trials of dapoxetine (Nieves Martín et al., 2025); combinations with sprays haven't been studied the same way. Many men use a spray as a bridge while they learn the stop-start technique, then rely on it less.

The bottom line

The best-evidenced delay spray is the licensed lidocaine–prilocaine spray (Fortacin), where it's available. In the US, over-the-counter lidocaine sprays such as Promescent and Stud 100 deliver the same 10 mg per spray of a proven ingredient, but neither product has a placebo-controlled trial. Whatever you choose, use the lowest labeled dose, protect your partner, avoid sprays when trying to conceive, and pair it with training if you want control that doesn't depend on a bottle. For the full shelf of non-prescription options, see premature ejaculation over the counter.

Frequently asked questions

Does Promescent work?

Its active ingredient, lidocaine, lengthens time to ejaculation in randomized trials of numbing products. The only published study of Promescent itself was a 14-day diary study of 91 men without clinical PE and with no placebo, which reported longer latency on use days, so product-specific evidence is weak.

Is Fortacin better than Promescent?

Fortacin has stronger evidence: it is a licensed medicine tested in placebo-controlled trials in men with lifelong PE. Promescent is a US over-the-counter lidocaine spray without a published placebo-controlled trial. They have never been compared head to head.

Is lidocaine or benzocaine better for premature ejaculation?

Direct comparisons are scarce. In one randomized study of 273 men with lifelong PE, a lidocaine spray lengthened latency more than benzocaine condoms, but the condoms caused the fewest side effects, and the products differed in delivery as well as ingredient.

Is a delay spray better than wipes?

Sprays usually deliver a measured dose of lidocaine; wipes usually contain benzocaine (for example 7% in one US product) and dose less precisely. Neither has been tested against the other, so choose by how reliably you can apply a small, consistent amount.

Is a delay spray better than Viagra for premature ejaculation?

They do different jobs. Numbing sprays reduce sensation; erection drugs such as sildenafil help most when erection problems are also present. For men without erection problems, evidence for sildenafil in PE is of unclear quality.

Sources

  1. Carson C, Wyllie M (2010). Improved ejaculatory latency, control and sexual satisfaction when PSD502 is applied topically in men with premature ejaculation: results of a phase III, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. The Journal of Sexual Medicine. Summary · doi:10.1111/j.1743-6109.2010.01913.x
  2. Martyn-St James M, Cooper K, Ren K, Kaltenthaler E, Dickinson K, Cantrell A, Wylie K, Frodsham L, Hood C (2016). Topical anaesthetics for premature ejaculation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sexual Health. Summary · doi:10.1071/SH15042
  3. Hamarat MB, Kafkaslı A, Kucuktopcu O, Ecer G, Yazıcı Ö, Karataş B (2025). Comparative efficacy of EMLA cream, lidocaine spray, and benzocaine condoms in treating lifelong premature ejaculation: a randomized clinical study. World Journal of Urology. Summary · doi:10.1007/s00345-025-06015-3
  4. Cai T, Gallelli L, Verze P, Salonia A, Palmieri A (2023). Prilocaine/lidocaine spray for the treatment of premature ejaculation: a dose- and time-finding study for clinical practice use. International Journal of Impotence Research. Summary · doi:10.1038/s41443-022-00554-8
  5. Alghobary M, Gaballah M, El-Kamel MF, State AF, Ismail SR, Selim MK, Mostafa T (2020). Oral dapoxetine versus topical lidocaine as on-demand treatment for lifelong premature ejaculation: A randomised controlled trial. Andrologia. Summary · doi:10.1111/and.13558
  6. Mark KP, Kerner I (2016). Event-level impact of Promescent on quality of sexual experience in men with subjective premature ejaculation. International Journal of Impotence Research. Summary · doi:10.1038/ijir.2016.31
  7. Sutton M, Hunn C, Summers-Colquitt RB, Chen SH, Kavoussi SK, Kavoussi KM, Kavoussi PK (2018). Promescent Has a Cytotoxic Impact on Fresh Human Sperm In Vitro. Urology. Summary · doi:10.1016/j.urology.2017.12.027
  8. Salonia A, Capogrosso P, Boeri L, Cocci A, Corona G, Dinkelman-Smit M, Falcone M, Jensen CF, Gül M, Kalkanli A, Kadioğlu A, Martinez-Salamanca JI, Afonso Morgado L, Russo GI, Serefoğlu EC, Verze P, Minhas S (2025). European Association of Urology Guidelines on Male Sexual and Reproductive Health: 2025 Update on Male Hypogonadism, Erectile Dysfunction, Premature Ejaculation, and Peyronie's Disease. European Urology. Summary · doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2025.04.010
  9. Shindel AW, Althof SE, Carrier S, Chou R, McMahon CG, Mulhall JP, Paduch DA, Pastuszak AW, Rowland D, Tapscott AH, Sharlip ID (2022). Disorders of Ejaculation: An AUA/SMSNA Guideline. The Journal of Urology. Summary · doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000002392
  10. Coupland CA, Su L, McGirr MEA, Hood S (2026). Prolonging ejaculatory latency with benzocaine paste-containing natural rubber latex condoms: findings from a randomized, three-way, cross-over study. The Journal of Sexual Medicine. Summary · doi:10.1093/jsxmed/qdag134
  11. Martyn-St James M, Cooper K, Ren S, Kaltenthaler E, Dickinson K, Cantrell A, Wylie K, Frodsham L, Hood C (2017). Phosphodiesterase Type 5 Inhibitors for Premature Ejaculation: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. European Urology Focus. Summary · doi:10.1016/j.euf.2016.02.001
  12. Nieves Martín M, Marín Novoa P, Avendaño-Coy J (2025). Dapoxetine combined with non-pharmacological approaches for lifelong premature ejaculation. A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Journal of Sexual Medicine. Summary · doi:10.1093/jsxmed/qdaf238
  13. Fortacin (lidocaine/prilocaine) spray: Summary of Product Characteristics (emc)
  14. DailyMed: Promescent (lidocaine) spray label
  15. DailyMed: Stud 100 male genital desensitizer (lidocaine) label
  16. DailyMed: Promescent Delay Wipes (benzocaine) label
  17. 21 CFR 348.10: Active ingredients for male genital desensitizers (Cornell LII)
  18. 21 CFR 348.50: Labeling of male genital desensitizers (Cornell LII)
  19. EMA: Fortacin (lidocaine/prilocaine) EPAR
  20. NHS: Ejaculation problems